Monday, April 1, 2013
Well, Now We Know!
Vaccines Produce Homosexuality, Says Italian Scientist Gian Paolo Vanoli.
It's a hoot, really, and not all that much more absurd than the standard scientific explanations we hear.
P.S. Another winner: Scientist Says Men Will Be Extinct in 5 Million Years. Which hardly matters, since another scientist has said that human beings are getting progressively less intelligent. It's going to be a race between plant-level IQs and the end of the Y chromosome.
Sunday, March 31, 2013
Reality Has No Name
Here's a good example of sloppy, lazy use of language. I saw an online advertisement today, consisting of the words "All Military Families Deserve Benefits, Regardless of Sexual Orientation." Families don't have sexual orientations. Individuals in families have sexual orientations, but they may not have the same ones: one partner may be gay, the other bisexual -- and their children, if any, may be straight.
What the ad meant, of course, was that same-sex couples should have the same privileges in terms of benefits that mixed-sex couples do. Which, I suppose, would mean that they'd have to be married: unmarried heterosexual couples don't get such benefits.
A related example: yesterday a colleague, moderating a GLB panel for an education class, explained to the audience that as teachers they may have students with "same-sex parents." What she said was that a child may have a parent of the same sex; in my case, that would have been my father. Not all children do have same-sex parents living with them. But that's not what my colleague meant. She meant that some children have two parents of the same sex. That's not necessarily the same thing as having gay or bisexual parents. A straight male friend of mine isn't married to the mother of his son; soon after the boy was born she married another man and had a child with him. Since the boy regarded both men as his fathers, he had three parents, two of whom were the same sex. (True, they weren't both his biological father, but the same is usually true in lesbian couples with children: only one is the biological mother, but both are moms.) As I've noticed before, "same-sex" -- which refers to the bodies of the people who are interacting, not to their sexual orientation or other essence -- is gradually taking on the meaning of "gay" or "lesbian," as when someone writes about "same-sex acts." (Similarly, I've seen references to LGBT individuals, but no individual can be gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgendered.)
We were speaking to a class for future teachers in the School of Education, and the instructor had sent the participants some advance questions and other material. The most interesting to me was information about "microaggression," a term I hadn't heard before though it has been around since 1970. I wish I'd saved the definition the instructor sent us, but Wikipedia's is close to it:
But I had reservations almost immediately. Since most white Americans, anyway, seem to have trouble grasping that you can be racist even if you've never lynched anybody or never owned a slave,
I gather from Chester M. Pierce's words as quoted by Wikpedia that microaggressions are by definition nonverbal. (I'm not sure whether the "often" in "often automatic, and nonverbal exchanges" is meant to modify only "automatic," or "nonverbal" also. Another definition, also quoted by Wikipedia, includes verbal behavior.) From the discussion in class when we spoke there, I could tell that the students were already blurring the meaning of "microaggression" to include all kinds of behavior, verbal and nonverbal, that didn't fit the definition of the term.
After the class, I looked for more information about microaggression on the Web, and found this tumblr-like blog, The Microaggression Project, discussed by the bloggers in an interview with Ms. magazine. I noticed quickly that many of the submissions weren't about microaggressions at all, but about overt expressions of bigotry -- call them "macroaggressions." I also noticed in the Wikipedia article that some researchers have begun multiplying varieties, "microinsult" and "microrape" for example. There are also "microaffirmations" and "microinequities." I don't think that these variations add anything useful to the concept, especially since so much behavior intended to reinforce power and status occurs without overt violence. The concept of institutional or structural racism, for example, dealt with subtle as well as overt forms of subjugation and privilege. Power isn't always exercised by violence; it's more effective if it works subtly, even subliminally.
Words like "microaggression" are easy to define, but apparently many people, even academics and trained professionals, have trouble learning and applying those definitions. They also inflate their meaning to the point where the terms lose precision, and sometimes any meaning at all. In the same way that "deconstruct" came to mean simply "analyze," rendering it redundant, "microaggression" seems to be headed toward meaning "racism," "sexism," or any other form of bigotry. In which case, why use it at all? I suspect that part of the appeal of these words is their Latinate abstractness, which has prestige for many people: using them makes the user feel powerful. Which isn't entirely a bad thing -- it was, after all, one of the reasons Raymond Williams wrote Keywords: to give working-class people and people without university backgrounds the knowledge they needed to use such words:
What the ad meant, of course, was that same-sex couples should have the same privileges in terms of benefits that mixed-sex couples do. Which, I suppose, would mean that they'd have to be married: unmarried heterosexual couples don't get such benefits.
A related example: yesterday a colleague, moderating a GLB panel for an education class, explained to the audience that as teachers they may have students with "same-sex parents." What she said was that a child may have a parent of the same sex; in my case, that would have been my father. Not all children do have same-sex parents living with them. But that's not what my colleague meant. She meant that some children have two parents of the same sex. That's not necessarily the same thing as having gay or bisexual parents. A straight male friend of mine isn't married to the mother of his son; soon after the boy was born she married another man and had a child with him. Since the boy regarded both men as his fathers, he had three parents, two of whom were the same sex. (True, they weren't both his biological father, but the same is usually true in lesbian couples with children: only one is the biological mother, but both are moms.) As I've noticed before, "same-sex" -- which refers to the bodies of the people who are interacting, not to their sexual orientation or other essence -- is gradually taking on the meaning of "gay" or "lesbian," as when someone writes about "same-sex acts." (Similarly, I've seen references to LGBT individuals, but no individual can be gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgendered.)
We were speaking to a class for future teachers in the School of Education, and the instructor had sent the participants some advance questions and other material. The most interesting to me was information about "microaggression," a term I hadn't heard before though it has been around since 1970. I wish I'd saved the definition the instructor sent us, but Wikipedia's is close to it:
Microagression usually involves demeaning implications and other subtle insults against minorities, and may be perpetrated against those due to gender, sexual orientation, and ability status. According to Pierce, “the chief vehicle for proracist behaviors are microaggressions. These are subtle, stunning, often automatic, and nonverbal exchanges which are ‘put-downs’ of blacks by offenders”. Microaggressions may also play a role in unfairness in the legal system as they can influence the decisions of juries.My immediate reaction to this concept was positive, since it's certainly true that most racist and other bigoted behavior takes forms other than overt violence and verbal abuse. But even people who throw around racist epithets will deny that they're racist; the real problem is getting them to recognize that such behavior and attitudes are racist (or sexist, etc.). Invoking a word like "microaggression" is not going to help. It can be useful for people who are discussing the varieties of bigoted behavior, but it should have no place in dealing with people whose behavior you're trying to change. A professional who doesn't have a non-jargon translation handy in those situations needs to go back to school.
But I had reservations almost immediately. Since most white Americans, anyway, seem to have trouble grasping that you can be racist even if you've never lynched anybody or never owned a slave,
I gather from Chester M. Pierce's words as quoted by Wikpedia that microaggressions are by definition nonverbal. (I'm not sure whether the "often" in "often automatic, and nonverbal exchanges" is meant to modify only "automatic," or "nonverbal" also. Another definition, also quoted by Wikipedia, includes verbal behavior.) From the discussion in class when we spoke there, I could tell that the students were already blurring the meaning of "microaggression" to include all kinds of behavior, verbal and nonverbal, that didn't fit the definition of the term.
After the class, I looked for more information about microaggression on the Web, and found this tumblr-like blog, The Microaggression Project, discussed by the bloggers in an interview with Ms. magazine. I noticed quickly that many of the submissions weren't about microaggressions at all, but about overt expressions of bigotry -- call them "macroaggressions." I also noticed in the Wikipedia article that some researchers have begun multiplying varieties, "microinsult" and "microrape" for example. There are also "microaffirmations" and "microinequities." I don't think that these variations add anything useful to the concept, especially since so much behavior intended to reinforce power and status occurs without overt violence. The concept of institutional or structural racism, for example, dealt with subtle as well as overt forms of subjugation and privilege. Power isn't always exercised by violence; it's more effective if it works subtly, even subliminally.
Words like "microaggression" are easy to define, but apparently many people, even academics and trained professionals, have trouble learning and applying those definitions. They also inflate their meaning to the point where the terms lose precision, and sometimes any meaning at all. In the same way that "deconstruct" came to mean simply "analyze," rendering it redundant, "microaggression" seems to be headed toward meaning "racism," "sexism," or any other form of bigotry. In which case, why use it at all? I suspect that part of the appeal of these words is their Latinate abstractness, which has prestige for many people: using them makes the user feel powerful. Which isn't entirely a bad thing -- it was, after all, one of the reasons Raymond Williams wrote Keywords: to give working-class people and people without university backgrounds the knowledge they needed to use such words:
I deliberately included some terms in it because I felt that people did not know their more interesting and complex social history, and so were often unsure about employing them, or recoiling from one of their meanings which had been heavily put to use by ruling-class papers or publicists. I wanted to give them confidence in their ability to use these terms [Politics and Letters (Verso 1979), p. 179].But Williams wrote Keywords primarily for university students, and it's clear they need it just as much. It may be for lack of such a resource that graduate students and professors keep messing up terms like "social construction," "essentialism," and other technical terms in their own fields. It's not enough simply to wave these terms around, they must be used correctly.
Friday, March 29, 2013
A Problem of Definition
A friend sent me a copy of Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can't Stop Talking by Susan Cain, published last year. She loved the book and recommended it highly to all her friends on Facebook. I was wary of it, partly because I'd recently tried to read Anneli Rufus's Party of One: A Loner's Manifesto (Da Capo, 2003) and became terminally annoyed within a dozen pages. But I promised I'd get to Quiet as soon as a copy became available at the library, and that's how a copy arrived in the mail.
I procrastinated, because I had a lot of books I wanted to get through first. But then I found I'd gotten through most of them, and Quiet was washed up, as it were, on the shore. So today I gave it a try, and got bogged down very quickly. I switched to William Benemann's Male-Male Intimacy in Early America, and found myself making notes about things I disagreed with, so I'm going to begin here by explaining why I object to Quiet. I'm determined to finish it eventually, because I love my friend, respect her intelligence, and feel obligated to get through the book -- but it is going to take a while. For now, here's how Susan Cain got off on the wrong foot.
Cain begins by telling the story of Rosa Parks, who on December 1, 1955, refused to give up her seat on a Montgomery, Alabama bus, and whose arrest set off the Montgomery bus boycott. She contrasts Parks with Martin Luther King, Jr. the eloquent preacher.
Even if Parks was a shy and humble person, and I have no doubt that she was, she was also an activist before she took her stand on that bus. She joined the Montgomery branch of the NAACP in 1943, and became secretary soon after. "I was the only woman there, and they needed a secretary, and I was too timid to say no," she said later, but she stayed in that post until 1957. And she did more than take the minutes: she investigated the gang-rape of a black woman in Abbeville, Alabama, participated in other actions, and not long before that day in 1955, she "had recently attended the Highlander Folk School, a Tennessee center for training activists for workers' rights and racial equality." So she was not a loner who walked into town one day and took on the bad guys: however quiet and shy she was, she knew the value of working with others, and knew she didn't stand alone. She knew that her arrest would lead to organized action; she wasn't the first black person to refuse to give up a seat on the bus, but she was the one chosen by the Montgomery civil rights organizations to support.
None of this is exactly obscure; so why does Cain perpetuate this myth? No doubt because it can be used to support her thesis, but the historical reality is quite different from her (and mainstream America's) version of the story.
Beyond that, do "timid," "shy," and "humble" really equal "introvert"? Maybe Rosa Parks was an introvert; I don't object to the classification, but Cain hasn't really given any reason to put her into that box. I'm an introvert, and I'm not particularly humble. Though I'm shy, I have also been a ham ever since I was a child; give me an audience to speak to or sing to, and you'd never guess I was shy, or introverted. From the list of famous introverts she provides in the introduction, it appears that she thinks "introverted" means "socially inept." As the Publishers Weekly reviewer said of Rufus's Party of One, it's a "compendium of everyone who was anyone who ever spent a moment alone". That set me to wondering. From what I remember and my mother's occasional remarks, I began to be less gregarious around the time I learned to read, and because reading came easily to me, I found books a fascinating world to explore; reading, like serious thinking, is something that you must do alone. (There are ways to read with other people, but they're slower.) There were probably other reasons and factors, but I think that was one of them for me.
Later in the book (I peeked ahead) Cain discusses Asian-American kids who live in communities with large numbers of serious students, so that they have a community of people to share their nerdy interests with. She still thinks they're introverts. I grew up in a small midwestern town, with few if any eager readers or scholars around, so I had no such community. Would my personality be different if I'd had a bunch of friends who loved to read? I can't know, but I suspect so. I've also read that European mathematicians and scientists are less likely to be monomoniacal isolates than their American counterparts; they're more likely to have a good grounding in the humanities as well as the sciences.
It seems that Cain embraces the very clichés and stereotypes she's set out to refute. She also thinks that the marginalization of the introvert is something new, and even peculiarly American. I doubt that just on principle: human beings are a social species, so a person who won't immerse himself or herself in the group will always be suspect. And unless you're devoted to the idea that there's something wrong with being different, is it really so bad to live on the margins of the Group? (Which doesn't mean you aren't still part of it.) It's a difficult job sometimes, but someone has to do it.
I procrastinated, because I had a lot of books I wanted to get through first. But then I found I'd gotten through most of them, and Quiet was washed up, as it were, on the shore. So today I gave it a try, and got bogged down very quickly. I switched to William Benemann's Male-Male Intimacy in Early America, and found myself making notes about things I disagreed with, so I'm going to begin here by explaining why I object to Quiet. I'm determined to finish it eventually, because I love my friend, respect her intelligence, and feel obligated to get through the book -- but it is going to take a while. For now, here's how Susan Cain got off on the wrong foot.
Cain begins by telling the story of Rosa Parks, who on December 1, 1955, refused to give up her seat on a Montgomery, Alabama bus, and whose arrest set off the Montgomery bus boycott. She contrasts Parks with Martin Luther King, Jr. the eloquent preacher.
I had always imagined Rosa Parks as a stately woman with a bold temperament, someone who could easily stand up to a busload of glowering passengers. But when she died in 2005 at the age of ninety-two, the flood of obituaries recalled her as soft-spoken, sweet, and small in stature. They said she was "timid and shy" but had "the courage of a lion." They were full of phrases like "radical humility" and "quiet fortitude." What does it mean to be quiet and have fortitude? these descriptions asked implicitly. How could you be shy and courageous?As so often, I found myself asking irritably, "What do you mean 'we'?" The idea of strong, quiet people is proverbial, even a cliché. Still waters run deep, for example. If Parks hadn't acknowledged it herself, I'd have suspected that the tributes she received had more to do with reassuring men (yes, and women) that she wasn't forward, she wasn't a termagant or a virago, she was a nice little woman who knew her place and just happened to find herself on the stage of History, almost by accident. She took a wrong turn on her way to the ladies' room, perhaps, and ended up under the bright lights. The work of black women in the Civil Rights movement and the Black Nationalist movement has too often been downplayed to appease male insecurity. That is certainly the way Parks has often been depicted, through no fault of her own, but it's false.
Parks herself seemed aware of this paradox, calling her autobiography Quiet Strength -- a title that challenges us to question our assumptions. Why shouldn't quiet be strong? And what else can quiet do that we don't give it credit for [2]?
Even if Parks was a shy and humble person, and I have no doubt that she was, she was also an activist before she took her stand on that bus. She joined the Montgomery branch of the NAACP in 1943, and became secretary soon after. "I was the only woman there, and they needed a secretary, and I was too timid to say no," she said later, but she stayed in that post until 1957. And she did more than take the minutes: she investigated the gang-rape of a black woman in Abbeville, Alabama, participated in other actions, and not long before that day in 1955, she "had recently attended the Highlander Folk School, a Tennessee center for training activists for workers' rights and racial equality." So she was not a loner who walked into town one day and took on the bad guys: however quiet and shy she was, she knew the value of working with others, and knew she didn't stand alone. She knew that her arrest would lead to organized action; she wasn't the first black person to refuse to give up a seat on the bus, but she was the one chosen by the Montgomery civil rights organizations to support.
None of this is exactly obscure; so why does Cain perpetuate this myth? No doubt because it can be used to support her thesis, but the historical reality is quite different from her (and mainstream America's) version of the story.
Beyond that, do "timid," "shy," and "humble" really equal "introvert"? Maybe Rosa Parks was an introvert; I don't object to the classification, but Cain hasn't really given any reason to put her into that box. I'm an introvert, and I'm not particularly humble. Though I'm shy, I have also been a ham ever since I was a child; give me an audience to speak to or sing to, and you'd never guess I was shy, or introverted. From the list of famous introverts she provides in the introduction, it appears that she thinks "introverted" means "socially inept." As the Publishers Weekly reviewer said of Rufus's Party of One, it's a "compendium of everyone who was anyone who ever spent a moment alone". That set me to wondering. From what I remember and my mother's occasional remarks, I began to be less gregarious around the time I learned to read, and because reading came easily to me, I found books a fascinating world to explore; reading, like serious thinking, is something that you must do alone. (There are ways to read with other people, but they're slower.) There were probably other reasons and factors, but I think that was one of them for me.
Later in the book (I peeked ahead) Cain discusses Asian-American kids who live in communities with large numbers of serious students, so that they have a community of people to share their nerdy interests with. She still thinks they're introverts. I grew up in a small midwestern town, with few if any eager readers or scholars around, so I had no such community. Would my personality be different if I'd had a bunch of friends who loved to read? I can't know, but I suspect so. I've also read that European mathematicians and scientists are less likely to be monomoniacal isolates than their American counterparts; they're more likely to have a good grounding in the humanities as well as the sciences.
It seems that Cain embraces the very clichés and stereotypes she's set out to refute. She also thinks that the marginalization of the introvert is something new, and even peculiarly American. I doubt that just on principle: human beings are a social species, so a person who won't immerse himself or herself in the group will always be suspect. And unless you're devoted to the idea that there's something wrong with being different, is it really so bad to live on the margins of the Group? (Which doesn't mean you aren't still part of it.) It's a difficult job sometimes, but someone has to do it.
Thursday, March 28, 2013
I Like Her Attitude
Today I'm reading Sexual Politics in Cuba: Machismo, Homosexuality, and AIDS (Westview Press, 1994) by Marvin Leiner. Though it was published during the Clinton administration, it tells me a lot I hadn't known about sexuality and gender in revolutionary Cuba. Leiner is an admitted heterosexual, and I believe I've seen some criticisms of his work in other academic writings on homosexuality in Latin America, but I'll check those after I finish reading the book. I have a few minor quibbles myself, but nothing that really affects the value of the book so far.
Leiner is also a socialist, and (or but?) he manages to rebut some criticisms of Castro without being uncritical of the regime. (He often points out that much of the official and unofficial persecution against Cuban gays has its parallels in the US and elsewhere: like OMG, the nasty Cubans won't let homosexuals serve in the military! When this book was written, we were excluded from the US military too.) He's been a scholar of Cuba for decades and has lived there for extended periods; he draws on his own interviews for this book. But for now I want to quote one of his sources, the director of the National Working Group on Sex Education (Spanish abbreviation GNTES), Monika Krause. Krause, from the former East Germany, moved to Cuba to work on their sex education program. Leiner quotes her lecture on homosexuality to Cuban doctors.
While I hope that they are better than this now, the same program before a roomful of American doctors in the late 1970s and early 1980s would probably have gone exactly the same way. American doctors weren't, until that time and possibly later, required to take any courses on human sexuality, even though general practitioners were sure to be asked questions about sex. This is one reason why straight doctors mostly failed to deal properly with the AIDS crisis as it unfolded; gay doctors were another story. Back to Krause:
When it's appropriate, and unfortunately it often is, I've said basically the same thing to classes which train teachers or social workers: you're entitled to your personal beliefs and opinions, but you are not entitled to impose them on your students and clients. (Just as I, an atheist, would not be entitled to tell Christians I was counseling or teaching that they'll be just fine if they give up their religious beliefs.) It's lovely to see someone else saying the same things.
Leiner is also a socialist, and (or but?) he manages to rebut some criticisms of Castro without being uncritical of the regime. (He often points out that much of the official and unofficial persecution against Cuban gays has its parallels in the US and elsewhere: like OMG, the nasty Cubans won't let homosexuals serve in the military! When this book was written, we were excluded from the US military too.) He's been a scholar of Cuba for decades and has lived there for extended periods; he draws on his own interviews for this book. But for now I want to quote one of his sources, the director of the National Working Group on Sex Education (Spanish abbreviation GNTES), Monika Krause. Krause, from the former East Germany, moved to Cuba to work on their sex education program. Leiner quotes her lecture on homosexuality to Cuban doctors.
Then I say, "I need you, from this moment on, to be capable of repressing your aversion, your hatred, because I need you to listen. You're doctors. You are not anybody from the street: you are doctors."[P.S. Krause's remark that "You are not anybody from the street; you are doctors" is probably unfair to people "from the street." Lower-class Latinos have wide differences of opinion and attitude to homosexuality, but I can say that in my experience, working-class people without college educations are generally not hostile to gays; they may consider it sinful, but hey, we're all sinners. Epithets like "a disease, a plague," are more likely to come from the more educated. I realize that Krause means merely to shame her audiences for their irrational vehemence, but to do so by appealing to their class prejudice -- in a socialist society! -- isn't an ideal approach.]
I try to teach this class with a lot of participation, and, sometimes, depending on the group, I also introduce skits. I tell the doctors that I need a volunteer. If nobody raises his or her hand, I continue: "You are my doctor; I am an adolescent boy." (That needs a lot of imagination.)
So I'm role-playing the boy, and I say to the young doctor: "You are the family doctor, and I am asking you what to do because I'm homosexual. I have a lot of problems, and I don't know what it is, and I want to change because I want to live in accordance with the ethical and moral rules of society. I don't want to be an outsider. Well, doctor, what shall I do? I need your help."
The members of the class don't know what to do. They are asking the same questions of me, calling on me for help. Well, then I say, "Tell me, every one of you, what are the main characteristics of a homosexual?" And I write their answers on the chalkboard: "a disease, a plague." They continue, and I put all the words on the board: weak character, anti-social, faggot, corrupt, deviant, degenerate, unnatural. All the familiar, terrible phrases.
While I hope that they are better than this now, the same program before a roomful of American doctors in the late 1970s and early 1980s would probably have gone exactly the same way. American doctors weren't, until that time and possibly later, required to take any courses on human sexuality, even though general practitioners were sure to be asked questions about sex. This is one reason why straight doctors mostly failed to deal properly with the AIDS crisis as it unfolded; gay doctors were another story. Back to Krause:
Several times when I am talking, they jump and shout, and I have to say, "Are you a doctor? Or are you illiterate?" When they ask for further clarification, I explain that we do not yet know the real essence of homosexuality. But neither do we know the real essence of heterosexuality. Only nobody is asking about that; everybody is asking about homosexuality. Our view was always that homosexuality is something bad, evil, something terrible, unnatural. I say, "We know a lot about what homosexuality is not. We have enough arguments to say that it is not what is on the board; of that I assure you." And we have no possibilities of carrying out research because our homosexuals in Cuba are still under obligation, if they respect themselves, to hide their condition. Not to do so would bring about the end of his or her life as an accepted human being ...I think I'm in love. I've often said that I don't like the term "common sense," but what Krause says here feels like common sense to me. Lest anyone protest that she's imposing "Western" ideas about sexuality and homosexuality on a non-Western society, let me point out that, first, Krause was brought in by the Cuban government to teach these things; and second, the homophobic attitudes of those doctors (not to mention Monsignor Leoni) are thoroughly Western. (As others have pointed out, when non-Westerners condemn homosexuality as a Western import, they are usually quite happy to cite Western bigots to support their views.)
Often when I teach this class, the doctors will interrupt me -- shouting, getting very agitated and losing their control. Sometimes they feel very ashamed when I have to calm them down. "Control yourself! You are doctors! You cannot behave this way in front of a patient; you can't. Even if you hate homosexuals, you cannot manifest the same behavior and attitude you just have with me."
And then I say, "Of course, I do not expect that you will change your attitude from today to tomorrow. I know what many of you are thinking: She is one of them because otherwise, she wouldn't say that. She is perverted; she is a lesbian, she is a feminist; she is a this or a that and so on. And I assure you, I was thinking the same things ten or fifteen years ago. But we have to be consistent with our humanistic conception of society ...
And then I tell them an anecdote. I attended the Latin American Congress on Sexuality and Sex Education in Venezuela two years ago. The representative of the Catholic Church, Bishop Monsignor Leoni from Caracas, gave a speech. He was condemning so many things, so many things. Delegates from the Congress asked him: "What is the position of the Catholic Church concerning homosexuality?" And the monsignor answered, "A homosexual can never be a good Catholic. The Catholic Church and homosexuality are antagonistic." People asked why. He answered, "Because it is so." "Why can't a homosexual be a good Catholic?" He replied, "Because he cannot."
Then I say to the class: "You are not allowed to answer as did the Bishop Monsignor Leoni of Caracas" [46-48].
When it's appropriate, and unfortunately it often is, I've said basically the same thing to classes which train teachers or social workers: you're entitled to your personal beliefs and opinions, but you are not entitled to impose them on your students and clients. (Just as I, an atheist, would not be entitled to tell Christians I was counseling or teaching that they'll be just fine if they give up their religious beliefs.) It's lovely to see someone else saying the same things.
Tuesday, March 26, 2013
Mom Quiz
Helen Keller has fascinated me since I was a child. She was still alive when I first heard of her, though she was very old and her health was failing. What moved me about her was not so much her heroism in overcoming her disabilities, but how she symbolized the importance of language and learning, of talking and reading and writing as ways of making sense of the world and making contact with other people. The famous and defining image of Annie Sullivan spelling W-A-T-E-R into young Helen's hand, leading to the revelation that the signs were connected to the water flowing over her other hand, is for me the key to all this. So is the fragility of our faculties. (The film Awakenings, about people who emerged from years of catatonia brought on by encephalitis lethargica to brief periods of awareness, affected me similarly.)
So when I found a copy tonight in a used bookstore of a children's biography of Keller, published in 1958 but kept in print until the early years of this century, it caught my attention. (The picture above isn't of the copy I found, by the way.) But what made me decide to buy it was the name of the author, Lorena Hickok. Does that name ring a bell for anyone else? Click through to find out who she was.
So when I found a copy tonight in a used bookstore of a children's biography of Keller, published in 1958 but kept in print until the early years of this century, it caught my attention. (The picture above isn't of the copy I found, by the way.) But what made me decide to buy it was the name of the author, Lorena Hickok. Does that name ring a bell for anyone else? Click through to find out who she was.
Ooooh, Snap! Oh, Wait ...
There's a confusion at the heart of the controversy over same-sex marriage, and it's noticeable in this question by Justice Sonia Sotomayor, posted online in an image file too damn bloated for me to put into this post.
The confusion I'm referring to is between the issue of same-sex marriage and the concept of "sexual orientation." It's true that homosexual and bisexual persons are probably more likely than heterosexual persons to want to marry someone of their own sex, but the issue isn't sexual orientation, it's the sexes of the people involved. It's been a popular derisory line of antigay bigots that homosexuals are free to marry, they just can't marry someone of their own sex. That line shows a deliberate cluelessness on the bigots' part, but it also is true. Quite a few homosexually or bisexually-inclined people have married spouses of the other sex.
Bisexuality throws a bit of a monkey wrench in this whole mess, by the way, not least because of the hostility to bisexuals so common among many gay people. A bisexual person isn't obliged by his or her "sexual orientation" to marry, if anyone, someone of his or own sex; it's possible that they'll marry someone of the other sex. If sexual orientation were the driving force in choosing a spouse, then logically bisexuals must be allowed two spouses at the same time, one of each sex. But that's a reductio ad absurdum, not a recommendation.
I've mentioned before the relevance of Loving v. Virginia to this controversy. In overturning state laws against interracial marriage, the Supreme Court did not postulate a "racial orientation" that drove the Lovings to marry someone of a different race, though given the virulent racism of the United States in those days it would have been a reasonable claim that they must have had a different nature to want to mix races like that. But that seems not even to have been thought of. (Ironically, by tying same-sex marriage to status, the same-sex marriage movement is assuming an "intraracial" model for marriage: gay people will marry other gay people, sticking to their own kind.) "Sexual orientation" was invented largely to claim that lovers of their own sex are driven to do so by a different (but murky and incoherent) biological nature, and that concept frames the debate about homosexuality in the US today, so much so that many if not most gay people think it's absolutely necessary if we're to claim our rights as citizens. Not only bisexuality as a separate "sexual orientation" but the more recently-added category "men who have sex with men" pose serious difficulties to the status approach, which is why most advocates of gay rights and same-sex marriage prefer to ignore them. But since bisexuals have been subsumed into the GLBTQ alphabet soup, it takes some serious thought control to bring that off.
In the context of a Supreme Court case it's easier: the issues are framed as narrowly as possible, and I don't expect the Court's resident bigots, Scalia and Thomas, to try to widen the frame; that would necessitate an intelligence about human sexuality and a subtlety of thought that neither ever seems to have displayed before. But I can't help wondering, and would love to ask Ms. Justice Sotomayor: what if it were established definitively that homosexuality is not a "status" but something else? The concept of sexual orientation, after all, is tied to very dubious and probably bogus science. After all, people are entitled by the Constitution to choose their religious affiliation, to speak their minds freely and not by inner compulsion. Why must the choice of one's spouse be thought to be so different from the exercise of other rights and freedoms?
JUSTICE SOTOMAYOR: Outside of the marriage context, can you think of any other rational basis, reason, for a state using sexual orientation as a factor in denying homosexuals benefits or imposing burdens on them? Is there any other rational decision-making that the government could make? Denying them a job, not granting them benefits of some sort, any other decision?The site where this quotation appeared touted it as "A Supreme Court Justice Takes Down An Anti-Gay Marriage Argument in 1 Minute." It includes a one-minute, twenty-second audio clip of the exchange, with another question that adds nothing substantial to the question already quoted. I don't understand how that headline follows from Sotomayor's questions. Nor does the site's comment connect, as far as I can tell.
MR. COOPER: Your honor, I cannot.
During a Supreme Court hearing to determine whether Proposition 8 (marriage shall only be between one man and one woman) was constitutional, a number of anti-gay marriage arguments got spectacularly demolished.I don't see any demolition, spectacular or otherwise, in Sotomayor's remarks. Maybe I'm missing something.
The confusion I'm referring to is between the issue of same-sex marriage and the concept of "sexual orientation." It's true that homosexual and bisexual persons are probably more likely than heterosexual persons to want to marry someone of their own sex, but the issue isn't sexual orientation, it's the sexes of the people involved. It's been a popular derisory line of antigay bigots that homosexuals are free to marry, they just can't marry someone of their own sex. That line shows a deliberate cluelessness on the bigots' part, but it also is true. Quite a few homosexually or bisexually-inclined people have married spouses of the other sex.
Bisexuality throws a bit of a monkey wrench in this whole mess, by the way, not least because of the hostility to bisexuals so common among many gay people. A bisexual person isn't obliged by his or her "sexual orientation" to marry, if anyone, someone of his or own sex; it's possible that they'll marry someone of the other sex. If sexual orientation were the driving force in choosing a spouse, then logically bisexuals must be allowed two spouses at the same time, one of each sex. But that's a reductio ad absurdum, not a recommendation.
I've mentioned before the relevance of Loving v. Virginia to this controversy. In overturning state laws against interracial marriage, the Supreme Court did not postulate a "racial orientation" that drove the Lovings to marry someone of a different race, though given the virulent racism of the United States in those days it would have been a reasonable claim that they must have had a different nature to want to mix races like that. But that seems not even to have been thought of. (Ironically, by tying same-sex marriage to status, the same-sex marriage movement is assuming an "intraracial" model for marriage: gay people will marry other gay people, sticking to their own kind.) "Sexual orientation" was invented largely to claim that lovers of their own sex are driven to do so by a different (but murky and incoherent) biological nature, and that concept frames the debate about homosexuality in the US today, so much so that many if not most gay people think it's absolutely necessary if we're to claim our rights as citizens. Not only bisexuality as a separate "sexual orientation" but the more recently-added category "men who have sex with men" pose serious difficulties to the status approach, which is why most advocates of gay rights and same-sex marriage prefer to ignore them. But since bisexuals have been subsumed into the GLBTQ alphabet soup, it takes some serious thought control to bring that off.
In the context of a Supreme Court case it's easier: the issues are framed as narrowly as possible, and I don't expect the Court's resident bigots, Scalia and Thomas, to try to widen the frame; that would necessitate an intelligence about human sexuality and a subtlety of thought that neither ever seems to have displayed before. But I can't help wondering, and would love to ask Ms. Justice Sotomayor: what if it were established definitively that homosexuality is not a "status" but something else? The concept of sexual orientation, after all, is tied to very dubious and probably bogus science. After all, people are entitled by the Constitution to choose their religious affiliation, to speak their minds freely and not by inner compulsion. Why must the choice of one's spouse be thought to be so different from the exercise of other rights and freedoms?
Monday, March 25, 2013
Outstaying Its Welcome
We didn't get the seven inches of snow that had been forecast last night, just two or three, but that's bad enough for the last week of March in south central Indiana. Flurries continued today, and are supposed to continue through tomorrow. So I'm going to use my displeasure over the weather as an excuse not to write much of a post today. (I'm also captivated by two different books that I'd rather continue reading. Might write about at least one of them when I'm done.)
Today's photo is from the Facebook page of one of my hometowns, probably taken in the 1920s. It just occurred to me, looking at it again now, what snow removal would have been like before the internal combustion engine took over; probably next to nonexistent. I've read about people digging a path to the barn and the outhouse and waiting for a thaw. It could be worse, but I'm an optimist: it could be better.
Today's photo is from the Facebook page of one of my hometowns, probably taken in the 1920s. It just occurred to me, looking at it again now, what snow removal would have been like before the internal combustion engine took over; probably next to nonexistent. I've read about people digging a path to the barn and the outhouse and waiting for a thaw. It could be worse, but I'm an optimist: it could be better.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


