It's probably just algorithms, but lately I've been seeing a lot of people claiming that the apostle Paul founded Christianity, turning the movement from a religion taught by Jesus to a religion about Jesus. This notion isn't new, and I consider it a crank theory, but along with the usual Village Atheist types (why would they care about this?) I see that Bart Ehrman has taken it up. He did a nice job of summing up the controversy a few years ago on his blog, dismissing the claim:
As it turns out, the question of “who founded Christianity?” turns out to be a difficult one to answer. It depends on your definition of the word “Christian.” Jesus’ followers during his ministry were certainly followers of Christ, so you could call them Christian by that standard, but their beliefs certainly did not match the beliefs of mainstream Christians today.
I personally tend to think of Jesus as the founder of Christianity. Whether it was Mary or Peter who first claimed to see him after his death, or it was Paul who was responsible for taking the message of his resurrection to the first gentiles, I believe their message was based on the man, Jesus.
But more recently he seems to be boosting it in his YouTube videos, not claiming that Paul founded Christianity but that his teachings go against what Jesus taught. My aim in this post is not to settle the question. As Ehrman indicated in that blog post, a good deal of the question depends on how you define "Christianity," not to mention "founded."
Beginnings are usually messy, especially beginnings of movements. There's a good book I've mentioned here before, Varieties of Religious Invention: Founders and Their Functions in History (ed. Patrick Grey, Oxford, 2016), which goes into the messiness not only of the founding of Christianity but of other religions. Did Gautama found Buddhism, did Moses found Judaism, did Confucius found Confucianism? The answers are less obvious than I thought. Robert Wilken's The Myth of Christian Beginnings is good on this question too. But you could also compare James Barr's Holy Scripture: Canon, Authority, Criticism (Westminster, 1983) and Bruce Metzger's The Canon of the New Testament: Its Origin, Development, and Significance (Oxford UP, 1987). Metzger would be a good place to start, because he was a conservative and pious Christian, which is explicit in the book - but he was a fine scholar, and doesn't hide the gaps and complications in his account.
As Ehrman said, much depends on your definition of "Christian." If you mean the teachings of Jesus, then Jesus would be the founder; if you mean the religion about Jesus that eventually took over the West, it's harder to say, because that religion changed, often radically, as it spread. What Ehrman forgets, like so many who share his opinion, is that no one knows what Jesus taught. I say "forgets" because Ehrman says, correctly, that the canonical gospels weren't written by Jesus' original followers ("eyewitnesses" according to apologists) or even by people who knew Jesus' followers. No one knows who wrote them, and there's no reason to believe that they record Jesus' teaching accurately. Ehrman has written about the unreliability of "oral tradition," the method by which the early church is supposed to have transmitted and preserved Jesus' teaching. Scholars mostly agree that the gospels of Matthew and Luke used the gospel of Mark as a source, but also that they felt free to change Mark as they pleased. The scholarly consensus is that the gospels were written anywhere from forty to eighty years after Jesus' crucifixion (30 or 33 AD), though the consensus changes over time, and lately some scholars are arguing that they were all written after 100 AD.
What this means, however, is that no one knows what the apostle Paul encountered as Jesus' teaching, so no one knows how or if he changed it. I've pointed out before that Paul claimed he wasn't taught by human beings, but directly by revelations of Jesus himself. There's also evidence that Jesus' original followers disagreed with each other on what Jesus expected from his followers. This is shown vividly in Paul's report that he clashed with Peter in Antioch, when Peter suddenly stopped eating with Gentile Christians after some representatives of Jesus' brother James came to town. If the book of Acts could be trusted (though it can't), Peter had received a revelation from Jesus years earlier that gave him permission to dine with goyim, so that question should have been settled; but apparently it wasn't. And this is just one issue.
So I get tetchy when Bart Ehrman claims confidently that Jesus "never taught" this or that doctrine. The gospels disagree not only with Paul, but with each other on Jesus' teaching about salvation, and according to all of them Jesus was maddeningly coy about who he was, what his mission was, and so on. The gospels do agree that his original followers didn't understand him, and indeed that they could not have understood him until he'd died and been resurrected. Ehrman, like other scholars, seems too sure that to him everything has been revealed. The odds are greatly against that, it seems to me.
The attacks on Paul, and the claims that he invented his own bad version of Christianity, go beyond this, however. One common line is that Paul never met Jesus in the flesh, which is true enough. (Neither did the authors of the canonical gospels.) But they go on to imply if not claim that he alone had visions, which he must have made up in order to boost his authority, or maybe he was mentally ill, or had been smoking funny mushrooms. It has often been suggested that Paul was epileptic, for example; most of the people who say that he was insane are less specific in their long-distance diagnoses. Most of these theories seem to be based on Acts's accounts of Paul's encounters with the risen Jesus, though the people who rely on Acts also tend to say that the Bible is just Bronze Age fairytales, so it's strange that they suddenly take parts of it literally.
The trouble with this is that Paul isn't the only New Testament figure who had visions. There was Peter, who as I just mentioned had a vision that gave him permission to ignore the rules of kosher. There was Ananias, who was visited by the risen Jesus to notify him that Paul would be visiting him after being blinded by his vision on the road to Damascus. And there was Stephen the Hellenist, who saw the Son of Man sitting at God's right hand as he was martyred.
But this doesn't go far enough. Jesus himself had visions, as when he saw the Holy Spirit descending on him after his baptism and a heavenly voice declared him God's beloved son. He had encounters with the devil, he saw Satan falling from Heaven, and he went around having conversations with demons. I had an exchange online with someone who said that the mentally ill in Jesus' day were thought to be possessed by demons. I asked him if he thought that the mentally ill would recognize Jesus as the Son of God, as they did in the gospels, and got no answer, just the insistence that these people were mentally ill. That Jesus talked to the demons didn't seem to be evidence that he was mentally ill, or some reason.
Additionally, Jesus' parents had visions to validate his conception by the Holy Spirit and to warn Joseph to move the Holy Family to Egypt to escape King Herod's wrath. A select group of Jesus' disciples had a visionary experience, called the Transfiguration, on a mountaintop, And of course various of them saw Jesus alive again after his execution, though they didn't always recognize him as Jesus. But for some reason only Paul's vision discredits him. Ehrman has a video in which he asks how Paul knew it was Jesus who appeared and talked to him. That's a fair question, but then how did Ananias know, how did Joseph know it was God who assured him it was all right that he'd been cuckolded by the Most High? And so on. I don't think that Paul actually saw Jesus, but I'm curious why only Paul is subjected to this scrutiny.
Where Jesus himself is concerned, the answer is obvious enough. It's okay to pick on Paul or Jesus' dopey disciples, but Jesus remains sacrosanct, even for many unbelievers. When you're dealing with someone who must not be criticized, you need a boogie-man, a scapegoat, on whom you can dump all your hostility, and why not Paul? Ehrman seems to share that reluctance to find serious fault with Jesus. He does acknowledge that Jesus was wrong in predicting the imminent end of the world and the final judgment, but it doesn't seem to bother him much; Jesus was still a good guy, still way cool. So he laughs at Paul as he never laughs at Jesus. And his fans, as shown in their comments on his videos, like that. They too believe that Jesus was a good man, a wise teacher, and everything bad is the fault of Paul and the later church.
Patrick Gray discusses the Jesus vs. Paul question in his chapter of Varieties of Religious Invention. The claim that Paul hijacked the Jesus movement and flew it to Rome goes back to the 18th century:
In a letter written a few years before his death, for example, Thomas Jefferson refers to Paul as the “first corrupter of the doctrines of Jesus.” Fellow revolutionary Thomas Paine calls him “that manufacturer of quibbles” whose writings have inspired a religion “very contradictory to the character of the person whose name it bears.” Mahatma Gandhi laments the “great distinction between the Sermon on the Mount and the letters of Paul.” H. G. Wells bemoans the way Paul “substituted another doctrine for … the plain and profoundly revolutionary teachings of Jesus.” Similarly blunt are the statements of James Baldwin (“The real architect of the Christian church was … the mercilessly fanatical and self-righteous Paul”), Carl Jung (“It is frankly disappointing to see how Paul hardly ever allows the real Jesus of Nazareth to get a word in”), and George Bernard Shaw (“No sooner had Jesus knocked over the dragon of superstition than Paul boldly sat it on its legs again…. He does nothing that Jesus would have done, and says nothing that Jesus would have said”). Paul’s fiercest critic is perhaps Friedrich Nietzsche, for whom he embodies “the opposite type to that of the life of the ‘bringer of glad tidings’: the genius in … the inexorable logic of hatred,” without whom there would be no “Christianity.”Some of these takes are due to the writers' reliance on outdated biblical scholarship, but mostly they indicate that they had read the New Testament with blinders on. The Sermon on the Mount, for example, includes not only touchy-feely stuff like the Beatitudes but the command to pluck out your eye if it leads you to sin. Infidels haven't done any better in later years. The Jesus of the gospels is a supernatural figure who walks on water, a demon-whisperer and faith healer, and it takes determined selective reading (aka cherry-picking) to reduce him to a simple, kindly country rabbi who just wanted everybody to be kind to one another.
The "Paulianity" theorists' caricatures of Paul are strange. They want to connect Paul to the much-later institutional church, but Paul was a freelance spirit-driven charismatic preacher at odds with anything like institutional religion; he was the kind of teacher someone like St. Augustine would have stomped on. But then so was Jesus. If you want to point to a proto-institutional figure, Jesus' half-brother James, who seems to have taken over the Jerusalem church sometime after Jesus' death, is a better candidate: he was famous for his traditional piety, and was able to intimidate Peter by the time Paul was active (see Galatians 2:11-14). But the Jerusalem church was probably wiped out in the Jewish revolt of 66-73 CE.
Why Paul was influential is not clear to me. His churches featured speaking in tongues, "prophecy," and other ecstatic phenomena; the order of worship he prescribed isn't found in later Christianity, certainly not in Orthodoxy or Roman Catholicism. Who preserved a selection of his letters, and why, is not known, and those who later forged letters in his name moved away from his style of worship and church organization. The canonical gospels probably didn't come from Pauline churches, but not from Jesus' original followers either: they weren't written in Aramaic, the language Jesus and the Twelve probably spoke, but in literary Greek. There's a yawning lacuna between Paul and Catholicism; as some scholar (Hans Conzelmann?) said, before about 150 CE you're dealing with Christian prehistory, an era of legend and heroes -- not with history.
I'm an atheist, and I'm not defending Paul here. I'm interested in what we know, the kind of evidence we have, and I'm annoyed by the way certain atheists (such as Bart Ehrman and his fan club, but many others) use Paul as a whipping boy to support their unaccountable fondness and unfounded arguments for Jesus. I say "unaccountable" because they are atheists, so their determination to rehabilitate a demigod from a book of "fan fiction" and "Bronze Age fairytales" baffles me. I hope I've shown why I reject their arguments.
But hey - we live in a free country with freedom of religion! You're free to invent any kind of religion you like, even though it's totally made up. You're even free to claim that you follow the Real Jesus and all the Bible thumpers are not real Christians, because you have no power to do anything about it. But at heart you're as authoritarian as they are, and I'm free to point and giggle and make rude noises at you.