Showing posts with label toni morrison. Show all posts
Showing posts with label toni morrison. Show all posts

Monday, October 1, 2012

You've Got To Be Carefully Taught

I read Toni Morrison's The Bluest Eye last week, just before I went out of town, so I didn't have time to write more about it.

As I read it, I was watching for the aspects Samuel Delany had criticized, not just the Fantasy Police but the demonizing of lighter-skinned African-Americans.  He was right, I think, but I'm not sure I'd have noticed it if he hadn't pointed it out.  I try to be alert to such things, but not being black, let alone lighter-skinned black like Delany, they don't hit home personally for me.  (He was also right about the uneven quality of the writing, but then The Bluest Eye was Morrison's first novel.)

The copy I read was an edition commemorating the twenty-fifth anniversary of The Bluest Eye's publication, and it included an afterword by Morrison that confirmed Delany's Fantasy Police accusation.  The afterword begins:
We had just started elementary school. She said she wanted blue eyes. I looked around to picture her with them and was violently repelled by what I imagined what she would look like if she had her wish [209].
On the next page:
Implicit in her desire was racial self-loathing. And twenty years later I was still wondering about how one learns that. Who told her? Who made her feel that it was better to be a freak than what she was? Who had looked at her and found her so wanting, so small a weight on the beauty scale? The novel pecks away at the gaze that condemned her [210].
A "freak," huh?  A couple of pages later Morrison remarked:
Because that moment was so racially infused (my revulsion at what my school friend wanted: very blue eyes in a very black skin; the harm she was doing to my concept of the beautiful)… [211]
I don't blame the schoolgirl Morrison for her visceral reaction to her friend's wish.  Children aren't nearly as open-minded as many sentimental adults like to imagine.  What disturbs me a great deal, and I do consider it blameworthy, is that the adult Morrison still hasn't gotten over it.  Her "gaze" condemns and shames a child for her fantasy.  I don't think the child wished to be a freak; that's Morrison's judgment.

As Delany remarked, if the girl had expressed the same wish after the 1960s, someone would just have told her to get tinted contact lenses.  True, white-centric standards of beauty have been harmful to black women's self esteem (though also to white women's -- let's not forget the long debates among white feminists on that subject), but Afro-centric standards would be no less restrictive.  Any time one kind of body is held up as a standard, it will exclude and downgrade those who don't conform to it, and most won't conform to it.  This isn't helped by African-Americans' own color prejudices: the standard beautiful African-American woman is lighter-skinned than her man, if I go by popular films made for and by African-Americans.

I immediately thought of what Robert Reid-Pharr wrote in Black Gay Man (NYU Press, 2001) a decade ago:
[George Jackson] warns Angela Davis of his brother Jonathan, “Tell the brothers never to mention his green eyes and skin tone. He is very sensitive about it and he will either fight or withdraw.”

Those telltale green eyes and that never quite dark enough skin create a rather precise index of the traditions of racial commingling that exist more or less comfortably under the sign of blackness. The black in America has the maddening tendency to reveal in her eyes, skin, hair, in her body a history of contact and conquest, of slavery and rebellion, in which the African is certainly central, but never alone. Thus, when George Jackson nominates the black domestic unit as one of our basic weaknesses, when he argues that there are deep structures that produce these weakness[es], he begins to turn us, however awkwardly, toward serious consideration of the fact that the black family is perhaps not quite so black as we might imagine. The work of the black family is precisely to enable the maintenance of a coherent structure of American racialism. Blacks, browns, yellows, red, and whites are given in black families access to a black body, the original body stolen from Africa, the innocent body, the body imagined as the site of revolution [65-6].
In fact, then, black babies have been born with green eyes and probably with blue eyes.  Morrison surely knows that as well as I do.  What is wrong, though unfortunately not freakish, is moralizing skin or eye color.

And then this turned up on the Intertoobz: some guy took a photo of a young Sikh woman with facial hair whose appearance he found confusing.  Word got around, the young woman heard about the picture, and posted her own commentary, forthrightly asserting her difference and her right to it.  Amazingly, the guy who'd posted the picture apologized for his original attitude, and it reads like a genuine heartfelt apology, not the I'm-sorry-I-got-caught kind that's the norm in American public life.  I admire the young woman's attitude, though I have some troubles with her dismissal of those who do modify their bodies: "By crying 'mine, mine' and changing this body-tool, we are essentially living in ego and creating a separateness between ourselves and the divinity within us."  That goes back to Delany's notion of Fantasy Police, and as one commenter at Jezebel pointed out, cutting fingernails and bathing also modify the "body-tool," to say nothing of wearing clothing.  Some body modifications, like circumcision, are demanded by some deities.  But it is still a moving exchange, and it inspired some interesting discussion in the comments.

Sunday, September 16, 2012

The Fantasy Police

While I was puttering around this morning after a late night, my eye lighted on Samuel Delany's On Writing (Wesleyan, 2005) and I decided to reread his remarks on Toni Morrison's novel The Bluest Eye.  That novel's premise is that a young black girl, living in the South on the cusp of the Second World War, becomes obsessed with the idea of having blue eyes and goes mad.  Quite mad.  I'm going to reread The Bluest Eye soon, I hope (I say that every time I think of Delany's critique, but this time I mean it), but my attention was caught today by this passage:
Morrison's novel aligns itself with the Fantasy Police.  Reading it, I find myself asking: What's wrong with wanting to be different from what you are?  The assumption that wanting to be other than you are means that you hate yourself is pathological and patently absurd.  A much clearer and more articulate argument might be posed that to desire effectively to be different, actually to expend energy to bring that difference about (to become surgically a woman if you are born a man; to become surgically a man if you are born a woman; to reconstruct your foreskin if you were circumcised before you could consent to it; to straighten your hair if you don't like it kinky; to wear blue contact lenses if you have brown eyes and dark skin; to wear dreadlocks if you were born with straight blond hair; to pierce, or tattoo, or or decorate your body in any way at all; to exercise or diet to contour your body toward whatever ideal you set yourself) requires much more self-confidence and a clear sense of who you are than those who never question or wish to adjust their bodily reality at all [166-7].
That is a long sentence, so don't lose sight of its beginning: that a much clearer and articulate argument to that effect might be posed.  I'm not sure I'd agree entirely with it myself, since I'm not sure what "a clear sense of who you are" is; I'd have to see a fuller articulation of it before I could decide.  But I still like his basic complaint.  Delany is black himself, and he's fully aware that "whatever ideal you set yourself" isn't necessarily a pure spark that comes out of a pure individual core: it's affected (though not completely determined) by the environment one grows up in.

I'd also argue that at least some decorations and other changes we may may make to our bodies aren't seen as recuperating or expressing our original selves before our parents conceived us.  People often try out different looks, even selves, without necessarily thinking of them as our essential being.  Whether a given modification feels like an expression of Self depends on the individual: the same look that represents a move toward the ideal for one person might just be this week's fashion statement for another.  But I think of this as an extension of Delany's point, not a refutation: why shouldn't people try on different selves, experiment with body ornament, and so on?  I don't think those experiments are rendered invalid if they don't last a lifetime.

Delany continues a couple of paragraphs later:
The accusation of self-hatred, whether racial or sexual (and notice, it is only blacks, only gays, only Jews, only women who are ever accused of hating themselves -- never straight white Protestant males ...), once we are attuned to it, always carries clear and persistent overtones of sour grapes from the accusers.  ... This has a common name in discussions of liberationist political analysis: blaming the victim [167].
Again, I go only part way with Delany here.  For one thing, it seems to me that straight white Protestant males are accused of self-hatred, usually under the name "liberal guilt" or (formerly) "radical chic."  If a man sides with feminism, a heterosexual with gays, a white person with anti-racism, a Jew with Palestinian struggle, he or she will be accused of self-hatred, and of inauthenticity at the very least.  (You can see this in many attacks on straight white Jewish Noam Chomsky: because he isn't poor, his criticisms on the privilege of the wealthy are hypocritical -- but if he were poor, he would be accused of mere envy of what he hasn't got.)  A blond, blue-eyed person who cultivates dreadlocks will be accused of cultural appropriation, if not overt racism.  Which is wack, if not racist itself.

Still, Delany's basic point is I think a good one.  (There's more to his critique of Morrison that's relevant here, but I'm not going to comment more until I've reread her book.)  I've written before about the same pattern among gay men seeking authenticity either in effeminacy or in machismo.  I think the two positions cancel each other out, but are to be opposed whenever they rear their heads.