I'm just too lazy to write at any length, but this might be worth noticing:
As numerous people pointed out to O'Brien, the Dante quotation is bogus. It's the opposite of the case in fact, though Dante didn't know any more about what happens after we die than anyone else does. But if you are going to cite fiction, you should at least get its details correct.
As I thought about it, however, it occurred to me that highly placed Republicans, including Trump himself, are anything but neutral about the impeachment inquiry: they are attacking quite fiercely the process and those who are carrying it out. So I guess they'll be going to Heaven, right? If anyone has tried to maintain neutrality, it's the Democratic Congressional leadership, notably Speaker Nancy Pelosi, who did her best to block and retard impeachment until her neutrality became untenable.
There's also dear Barack Obama, last seen being moderate and neutral and reasonable about "cancel culture." (It should be remembered that he's always been dismissive of those who don't stop with clicking on the Intertubez, but organize and mobilize and take to the streets -- especially in opposition to his policies.) But I'm not being quite fair, because Obama isn't neutral: he's ready to act in support of the people who share his values.