Saturday, March 9, 2013

In Post-Post-Racial America

Ta-Nehisi Coates recently wrote an op-ed for the New York Times that has been getting some well-deserved attention.  He began with an incident that befell the actor Forest Whitaker in a deli near Columbia University, in Coates's own neighborhood.  An employee, suspecting Whitaker of shoplifting, insisted on frisking him in public.  Whitaker didn't call the police at the request of the employee, who was fearful of losing his job, but he lost his job anyway.

Some of the comments under the op-ed are appalling, like this one from "Scott" in Chicago:
I am starting to have misgivings about articles like these: All that is good in the world (that I have observed) comes from tolerance and a willingness to forgive. Nothing ever good stems from quests for perfection and purity.
That one got 764 recommendations.  I see no basis in Coates's op-ed for Scott's accusation that Coates is on a quest for perfection and purity.  It would be closer to the truth to say that Scott is demanding "perfection and purity" from the targets of American racism.  But I started to have misgivings about people like Scott long ago.

Then there was this one, from "Ross" in Rochester NY:
You cannot take one data point and extrapolate it into a conclusion. When you do that, you're guilty of the same behavior that allows people to see a black murderer on the news and conclude all blacks are bad people.
Of course there is not just one "data point", there are many.  This is a popular tactic: accuse the critic of being obsessed with one isolated incident, then as the isolated incidents multiply, change the subject: the critic is indulging in "reverse racism," or dwelling on events that happened long ago, or something like that.  But the attempts by many white people to minimize racism in the US constitute data points, with a multiplier effect as they try to deny the significance of the original events.

Then there's Jorg Lueke from Minnesota:
I hope that the author has recovered from his fatigue of good people. The attitudes of guilt, victimization, and anger, are understandable for a moment but they are not attitudes to live by if we want to live in a society where prejudgements no longer occur. The owner commited no wrong act and yet now both author and wife will spread negative feelings and emotions every time they see this deli potentially infecting their friends and children. Will that make things better? For what really? Because they read about someone else being treated poorly once by an employee? We need to work on living in the moment and acting in the momeent with lover, understanding, and compassion. Compassion for Forrest Whitaker, compassion for the Deli owner, compassion for the employee. Guilt and anger do not break the cycle.
Notice: "someone else being treated poorly once by an employee" -- the Gothamist article I cited above included a report by an eyewitness to the frisking on Forest Whitaker that she has "seen the guys there do this to a black customer before. I have also heard them say some racist crap about the Obamas too. It is unlikely I will be shopping there again."  So it's not "being treated poorly once", though how many times can you treat one person poorly before it becomes a problem?  Jorg Lueke seems to be notably lacking in "compassion" for people who must endure poor treatment constantly: he sees them as bitter complainers.  He also fails to show compassion for Ta-Nehisi Coates, who in the op-ed clearly expressed his conflicted feelings about what to do.

Best of all, "Ralphie" from Fairfield CT:
Yes racism is a terrible thing -- and to be called a racist, or have it inferred that you are a racist simply on the basis of your skin color is also a terrible thing.
This is what is known as false equivalence, as well as lying: Coates had not called anyone a racist "simply on the basis of the color of your skin."  (I've often encountered this tactic in online discussions of gay issues: if I refer to "homophobes" or "bigots", someone will accuse me of assuming that all heterosexuals are bigots.  Since I hadn't said anything like this, it becomes clear that they assume that "homophobe" and "heterosexual" are equivalent.  But they aren't: many heterosexuals are neither homophobic nor bigots, and many gay people are homophobes and antigay bigots.)  Ralphie goes on to express his belief that "we've made great progress over the last 50 years" -- against the resistance of people like him, I'd say -- and begs us not to "cast the 'R' word about as if it explains every unhappy event."  The "'R' word"!

Coates also posted to his blog at the Atlantic about the incident and the op-ed.  The discussion in comments there is much better than at the Times.  Like this comment, the first in the thread:
What I don't think white people understand is the collateral damage this causes to black people who have to deal with what Forest Whitaker went through, from a psychological point of view. You start to see ghosts. You think you see racism everywhere in your interactions with white people. For some, it becomes such a problem that is inhibits their own personal/career growth.
I'm a white person, and I understand that collateral damage at least intellectually.  I have tried to imagine what it would feel like to have grown up knowing that hostile people were looking at me, waiting for an excuse to yell epithets at me, or better, to get me alone in a secluded place and beat me up?  Or seeing me as a threat, just for existing in the space they consider to be theirs?  The closest I've come to feeling it has been some occasions when I was out for a walk late at night, and was almost the only person in sight on a street -- except for a woman who I could see gather into herself at the sight of me, not knowing whether I was a threat or not.  Some men get indignant about that; I don't.  It doesn't begin to compare to growing up black in America, and I'm not saying that it does.  Most of the time I'm invisible in white society; black people never are, from the day they're born.

Some would argue that I have a double standard here.  I've been asked what I would think, while I walked down an empty city street late at night, if I saw a group of  young black men approaching.  I would feel somewhat apprehensive, it's true, but no more than I feel when I see a group of young white men approaching.  The 18-35 age group among males commits most crimes, I believe.  But I have been out walking late at night in large American cities and passed groups of young black men who paid me no attention at all.

Coates commented in reply, "From a cold calculating position, even if it is racism you can't know. There's nothing you can do about it, so you shouldn't bother thinking about it."  But not thinking about it doesn't always work.

Someone else posted a great quotation from Martin Luther King that I will hang on to:
Now the other myth that gets around is the idea that legislation cannot really solve the problem and that it has no great role to play in this period of social change because you’ve got to change the heart and you can’t change the heart through legislation. You can’t legislate morals. The job must be done through education and religion. Well, there’s a half-truth involved here. Certainly, if the problem is to be solved, then in the final sense, hearts must be changed. Religion and education must play a great role in changing the heart. But we must go on to say that while it may be true that morality cannot be legislated, behavior can be regulated. It may be true that the law cannot change the heart, but it can restrain the heartless. It may be true that the law cannot make a man love me, but it can keep him from lynching me, and I think that is pretty important, also.
--Martin Luther King, Jr., Address at Western Michigan University, December 18, 1963
(You may remember, as I do, a distinguished white philosopher from England who couldn't grasp the point King was making here.)

Some commenters seemed to miss King's point (though maybe I flatter myself by supposing that I get it).  One said that "No, you can't use legislation to make people less racist but you can use it to erase the racism that was legislated into existence."  Another said that passing a law against lynching is "quite good enough."  King said, "I think that is pretty important, also", which seems to me quite different than "quite good enough."  King didn't deny that other institutions besides the law must be active against racism -- he was rejecting the claim that because the law can't do everything, it can therefore do nothing and shouldn't be tried.

I don't know how much progress we have made against racism in the US.  Certainly there has been some, but not as much as most white people evidently want to believe.  Many racists have learned to avoid blatant expressions in public, but they keep leaking out anyway.  To some extent the Internet has facilitated their exposure, as people assume that what they say online is "private," even as it is publicly accessible; so you get incidents like the racist Hunger Games fans who were furious to find that some of the characters were black, and were played by black actors in the film.  And then you have "a fellow on Twitter by the handle of 'YesYoureRacist' who simply re-tweets people whose tweets are of the form 'I'm not racist, but [horrible thing]' -- it's an astonishing thing to see them all collected in one place."  Or the white Louisiana judge who refuses to marry 'interracial couples': "I'm not a racist, I just don't believe in mixing the races that way."  Besides, he has lots of black friends!

I don't have any conclusion today, because there is no conclusion.  This story is going to be in progress for a long time.

Thursday, March 7, 2013

A Meme of One's Own


I'm not in the mood to write today, so I'll just leave you with the above thought.  I've finally embarked on a project I've had in mind for some time: to make my own memes.  The one up there is one of my first, and just in case you're wondering, the misspelling of "Buddha" is deliberate.

Wednesday, March 6, 2013

An Injury to One Is an Injury to All

My liberal friends are very fond of the word "class," though not in a political-economy or sociological sense -- rather a cultural one: Barack and Michelle are so classy!  Well, not only liberals: there was a right-wing meme going around a week or two back, consisting of photos of Nancy Reagan, Barbara Bush, Laura Bush, and Michelle Obama, with the caption Remember when First Ladies had class? Well, no I don't, now that you ask.  Laura Bush was in my opinion the best of that creepy GOP batch, and I don't actively hate Michelle Obama -- it's just that the word "class" has no real meaning in this context, and besides, when you're reduced to judging a presidential administration by the coolness of the President's wife, you're pretty much signaling that you have turned off whatever intelligence you had to begin with, which in most cases was not much.

The word "class," used in this way, reliably sets my teeth on edge: it points to stuff like accent, looks, dressing stylishly, possessing a certain je ne sais quoi that says "I'm better than those debased, watermelon-eating, cousin-marrying trailer dwellers out there," and that allows the fan to identify with the classy person even (or especially) if the fan lacks all those traits oneself.  It's a lot like participating vicariously in the victories of a sports team, sharing in its glory even if your sole athletic skill is working a remote.  But as I say, my liberal friends are big on this, no doubt because of "class" anxieties and insecurities of their own.  When I reminded one of them of the riots that followed our own little school's last half-successful basketball season, he said, "Let's hope we can celebrate with a little more class this time."  That was quite stupid, if only because the rioters were mostly privileged white kids, the kind whose skulls the cops never crack, the kind who see someone else's car as something to be overturned, the kind whose yards in my neighborhood are covered with refuse for days, even weeks, after their parties.  They're the kind of people who set the tone for these celebrations: rioting after a sports victory is a hallowed IU tradition, and what could be classier than Tradition? But as Raymond Williams remarked of his Cambridge days, "nobody fortunate enough to grow up in a good home, in a genuinely well-mannered and sensitive community, could for a moment envy these loud, competitive and deprived people."

Nice middle-class people have sometimes tried to reassure me that I'm one of them, because I read and I think and I'm smart and I don't talk like trailer trash.  Increasingly, as I observe them, I don't think so: reading and thinking are among the things that show I'm not like them.

But what I'm thinking of is Hugo Chávez, who, whatever his failings, had no "class" in this sense at all, which is one of the things I like about him.  That he had respectable pundits and politicians (who felt a sense of personal kinship with the worst tyrants in the world) foaming at the mouth because he disrespected Our Dear Leader at the United Nations was an added bonus.  (Was that moment "scripted"?  Who cares?)  According to a piece by Greg Grandin at The Nation, however, Chávez' shtick was to a great an extent an act, a conscious performance.  Granted, Chávez was low-class by background: he was "the second of seven children, born in 1954 in the rural village of Sabaneta, in the grassland state of Barinas, to a family of mixed European, Indian and Afro-Venezuelan race ... he was sent to live with his grandmother since his parents couldn’t feed their children".  This wouldn't be held against him if his rise had consisted of allying himself with the wealthy and powerful instead of opposing them, of course.
The high point of Chávez’s international agenda was his relationship with Brazil’s Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, the Latin American leader whom US foreign policy and opinion makers tried to set as Chávez’s opposite. Where Chávez was reckless, Lula was moderate. Where Chávez was confrontational, Lula was pragmatic. Lula himself never bought this nonsense, consistently rising to Chávez’s defense and endorsing his election.

For a good eight years they worked something like a Laurel and Hardy routine, with Chávez acting the buffoon and Lula the straight man. But each was dependent on the other and each was aware of this dependency. Chávez often stressed the importance of Lula’s election in late 2002, just a few months after April’s failed coup attempt, which gave him his first real ally of consequence in a region then still dominated by neoliberals. Likewise, the confrontational Chávez made Lula’s reformism that much more palatable. Wikileaks documents reveal the skill in which Lula’s diplomats gently but firmly rebuffed the Bush administration’s pressure to isolate Venezuela.

Their inside-outside rope-a-dope was on full display at the November 2005 Summit of the Americas in Argentina, where the United States hoped to lock in its deeply unfair economic advantage with a hemisphere-wide Free Trade Agreement. In the meeting hall, Lula lectured Bush on the hypocrisy of protecting corporate agriculture with subsidies and tariffs even as it pushed Latin America to open its markets. Meanwhile, on the street Chávez led 40,000 protesters promising to “bury” the free trade agreement. The treaty was indeed derailed, and in the years that followed, Venezuela and Brazil, along with other Latin American nations, have presided over a remarkable transformation in hemispheric relations, coming as close as ever to achieving Bolívar’s “universal equilibrium.”
There are other intriguing anecdotes in Grandin's piece, like the one that gives
the lie to the idea that poor Venezuelans voted for Chávez because they were fascinated by the baubles they dangled in front of them. During the 2006 presidential campaign, the signature pledge of Chávez’s opponent was to give 3,000,000 poor Venezuelans a black credit card (black as in the color of oil) from which they could withdraw up to $450 in cash a month, which would have drained over $16 billion dollars a year from the national treasury (call it neoliberal populism: give to the poor just enough to bankrupt the government and force the defunding of services). 
(Dangling baubles in front of the rich -- tax breaks, cutting services to the poor, "austerity" -- is not just acceptable but the natural order of things in "classy" politics.)

Grandin also tells of Chávez successfully lobbying Lula and then-Argentinian president Kirchner on a proposal to give debt relief to numerous poor countries in Latin America.
Chávez asked a number of thoughtful questions, at odds with the provocateur on display on the floor of the General Assembly ... We later got word that Chávez had successfully lobbied Lula and Kirchner to support the deal. In November 2006, the IADB announced it would write off billions of dollars in debt to Nicaragua, Guyana, Honduras and Bolivia (Haiti would later be added to the list).
I've felt hesitant to write about Chávez (but here I am, with my second post in twenty-four hours), because I really do believe that personalities are less important than issues.  I'm not interested (except lustfully, which is moot now) in Chávez so much as whether the organizations he worked with will be able to adapt and protect their gains after he's gone. This is why I've found myself defending Obama and Bill Clinton against right-wing attacks, and even Bush and Romney against liberal ad hominems. As I wrote before, only time will tell whether the good things he built in Venezuela will survive him; I've already seen his critics gloating, and there was already a celebration at the Atlantic's site last night. But he clearly did build alliances in Latin America that have made some breathing space for freedom there, and if you want to blame anyone for his ascendancy, blame George W. Bush, who overextended US power with his brutal, expensive wars and weakened its influence in Latin America and elsewhere.  In that area, as in so many others, Obama has followed in Bush's footsteps.

But one thing I do know: a major reason Chávez was hated so much by US elites was that he had no class.  This morning Democracy Now! did a segment on post-Chávez Venezuela, also featuring Greg Grandin.  Eva Golinger, one of the participants and an associate of Chávez, described how the Venezuelan vice president, Nicolás Maduro a former bus driver and union activist, was attacked by the opposition: "Oh, he’s a bus driver. You know, he knows nothing. He has no education. How could he be the top diplomat of the country?" When I look at how ignorant and stupid the properly entitled people (commonly known as the "meritocracy") have consistently shown themselves to be, I figure a bus driver couldn't do any worse.  As things turned out, it appears that he did much better.  But those attacks also remind me what most of the rulers think of the people they rule, and I know which side I'm on.

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

The Vultures Are Circling

I just heard that Hugo Chavez has died, and I must say that matters more to me than the latest deaths of TV sitcom stars and the like.  I'm not uncritical of Chavez, he did make some moves I objected to, and it seems he abused power at times.  I put it tentatively like that because the corporate media were so dedicated to lying about him that it became more trouble than it was worth to distinguish lies from truth where Chavez was concerned; I just tended to assume that everything bad I heard about him was false, except on the rare occasions when it came from someone more or less trustworthy.  When it comes to human rights violations and abuses of power, though, Chavez didn't begin to compare to any number of rulers the US has propped up to the bitter end -- to say nothing of our own President.

My real worry is whether Venezuela will be able to maintain the good things Chavez worked for.  The main thing that bothered me about his electoral successes was that they were too tied to his person, and it was hard to tell whether a political culture was growing in Venezuela that would survive him.  I guess we'll find out now.

I expect a lot of material from right-wingers and centrists to turn up on Facebook celebrating Chavez' death, so I'm girding my loins and opening a big can of whoop-ass.  But part of me is asking quietly, "What's the use?"  I imagine that will pass once the monkeys start throwing their handfuls of fecal matter.  Still, it's a valid question.  Ta-Nehisi Coates has a good post today about the national "Conversation on Race":
Writers who focus on race/gender/sexual orientation are often of the mind that the issues that they are tackling have, somehow, never been tackled before, or if so, have not been tackled "honestly" or "forthrightly" or "candidly." In the arena of race, the notion that Americans "don't talk about race" is a particularly pernicious rendition of this logic. I've never actually found this to be true. On the contrary, there's a lot of literature on the subject -- some of it enlightening, some of it clueless, and some of it racist. The sheer amount of material should, theoretically, raise the bar for "writing about race."

But because Americans actually enjoy yelling about race a great deal, it does not.
He might have qualified that first sentence by specifying "writers for corporate media", but you know what he meant, don't you?  There is a lot of good "literature" on all those subjects (race/gender/sexual orientation, and he could have added religion or politics in general), but little of it turns up in the corporate media.  (Coates himself is one of the notable exceptions.)  That's not because of a conspiracy, but because the people who run the media are generally not very knowledgeable about anything, and writing that strays from the corporate center with all its squishy goodness will be found to be "not right for us, thanks."  So the same tired cliches on controversial subjects persist for decades and more, and as I've gotten older I've found that more and more dispiriting.  Sure, I keep myself sane by reading outside the corporate media, but sooner or later I have to face what the mainstream is saying: the same old same-old.

An instructive example is a post that also appeared on the Atlantic's site, explaining why Cuba will still be anti-American after Castro.  At first glance I thought it had possibilities: someone could write a good article about the reasons Cubans have to look askance at the US: invasions, terrorism, multiple assassination attempts on Castro, and economic warfare in the form of a decades-long blockade aimed at starving the Cuban people into submission. This article, however, wasn't it: it was all about Fidel and Raul find it politically expedient to blame the US for all of Cuba's problems (which works so well because the US is to blame for many of Cuba's problems) as they pack the government with loyalists, more elderly revolutionaries, and their own kids. These would be good points if they were put in context, but author Jaime Suchlicki isn't interested in context, just in the perfidy of the Castro brothers. He has not a word to say about the dictatorships the US supported in Cuba before the Revolution, nor about US attempts after the Revolution to return Cuba to its proper place in our sphere of influence.  To talk about Castro's anti-Americanism as though it were a total fabrication in the face of US benevolence, which is what Suchlicki does, is to mark his article as "clueless" at best  in Coates's classification scheme, which means it's perfectly mainstream.

Sunday, March 3, 2013

Ten Years After

James Fallows has been writing about Bush's invasion of Iraq as its tenth anniversary approaches, and yesterday he posted some comments from his readers.  This one startled me: Alan Thomas, a guy who says he's "proud to be known as a liberal hawk."  He was profiled in the Washington Post, for whom he says he "filled the role of token leftist."  (That tells you something about corporate media's approach to the war, doesn't it?  They found a leftist who favored the invasion, and apparently figured that was enough diversity.)

His take on the coming invasion was also interesting, for a leftist:
The United States, Thomas says, "should clean up the world. We have the power.  I'm kind of a weirdo. It's wrong for us to sit on our hands and not do anything."
Bear in mind, he thought George W. Bush was going to "clean up the world."  Of course the US has been claiming to do that all along, and we've only made it dirtier.  Thomas told the WaPo that he was going to be on the alert for human rights violations.  "'If Bush tries to install a puppet dictator or if there are human rights violations, I'll be decrying it as loudly as anyone else on the left,' he said."

Ten years later, Thomas is unrepentant, having come up with new reasons for the war.  He wrote to Fallows:
Honestly, although my personal motive had to do with human rights ..., I think just the assassination attempt on Bush 41 is plenty all by itself--what kind of country are we if we let another country's leader pull something like that with impunity?

I have trouble understanding why you think it's so obvious now that the liberal hawks were wrong.  Maybe circa 2006 it looked that way, but aren't Iraqis better off today than they would be if Saddam (or his sons) still had a grip on power?
Ah, the assassination attempt on Bush 41.  That was only taken seriously at the time by Bill Clinton (who bombed Iraq in 1993, ostensibly in retaliation for it), and perhaps by Dubya himself.  It didn't play much of a role in the campaign of lies Bush-Cheney and their collaborators waged to justify the war, perhaps because the story had been mostly discredited.  Now it hasn't a leg to stand on: the invaders found no evidence in the records of Saddam's regime that it had ever happened.

The US has also attempted to assassinate foreign heads of state, notably Fidel Castro.  Does Alan Thomas wonder what kind of country Cuba is if they let another country's leaders pull something like that off with impunity?  Surely an invasion with some regime change is long overdue.

As for whether Iraqis are better off today with Saddam gone, that's hard to answer.  Many Iraqis don't think so.  It's certainly not for an American, scrambling to justify his support for the war, to say.

By an interesting coincidence, a writer at the Guardian today, Nick Cohen, defended his own support of the war.
Every few months a member of the audience at a meeting I am addressing asks whether I regret supporting the overthrow of Saddam Hussein ... I reply that I regret much: the disbanding of the Iraqi army; a de-Ba'athification programme that became a sectarian purge of Iraq's Sunnis; the torture of Abu Ghraib; and a failure to impose security that allowed murderous sectarian gangs to kill tens of thousands.

For all that, I say, I would not restore the Ba'ath if I had the power to rewind history. To do so would be to betray people who wanted something better after 35 years of tyranny. If my interrogators' protesting cries allow it, I then talk about Saddam's terror state and the Ba'ath's slaughter of the "impure" Kurdish minority, accomplished in true Hitlerian fashion with poison gas.
And, he might have added, with the support of the Reagan administration, who supplied Saddam's regime with the materials to produce that poison gas, and protected him from any consequences.   In 1983 Reagan's special envoy Donald Rumsfeld traveled to Baghdad to shake Saddam's hand and assure him of America's continued support, no matter what he did to the Kurds.

Cohen tries to insinuate that anyone who still thinks the invasion of Iraq was a bad idea must miss Saddam and wish he was still in power.  This is absurd, because the principled opponents of the invasion had always opposed Saddam and criticized the US and Britain for supporting him.  It's an astoundingly dishonest performance, repellent in its disregard for history.
If Bush was against dictatorships, Obama would "reset" relations with Russia and Iran and treat them as partners. The failure of his initiatives never deters him. Despite his efforts, Russia remains a mafia state and Iran remains a foul theocracy determined to acquire the bomb. Their peoples, naturally, are restive. Russians demonstrate against Putin's rigged elections. The Iranian green movement tries to overthrow the mullahs. But Obama and the wider tribe of western liberals have little to say to them.
In the real world, Bush was never against dictatorships: he was quite comfortable with Mubarak in Egypt and with the Saudi regime, for two obvious examples.  Iran is not pursuing a nuclear weapons program as far as anyone -- certainly not Cohen -- knows. and Obama was threatening war against Iran as long ago as 2007.  Cohen says that "Arab liberals now want nothing to do with the supposed leader of the world's liberal left," but says nothing about Obama's efforts to keep Mubarak in power, or his support for the Saudi and Bahraini regimes.

I can't speak for everyone on the left or everyone who opposed Bush II's invasion, of course, but I have no sympathy for Saddam and would not want him restored to power.  But I think he could have been removed from power much sooner and with less horrific human cost if the US had simply let him fall, instead of propping him up, as we did consistently until we decided to take him out.  There were always Iraqis who opposed Saddam and favored democracy in Iraq.  Not surprisingly, the US wasn't interested in them; when the time came we chose a thoroughly corrupt huckster as our official Iraqi-in-exile.  Bush did not intend to allow elections in the new regime: only huge nonviolent demonstrations by Iraqis forced him to permit them to take place -- and then he ignored the results.  The last thing the US government was ever interested in was a democratic Iraq.

Confidentially, I'm Gay

Conor Friedersdorf gave over a blog post to "a gay, celibate Christian's conflicted take on gay marriage."  That promised to be somewhat interesting, and it was, as far as it went.  As I've said before, I believe in teaching the conflicts, and it's important to hear as many different viewpoints as possible.  Which doesn't mean they're all equally respectable, of course.

Friedersdorf's guest introduces himself as "a politically moderate Christian" and "a biologically gay man."  Even if it were reasonably certain that homosexuality is a biologically-determined condition, which it is not, there is no way at present to distinguish "a biologically gay man" from a non-biologically gay man.  Invoking biology here is a declaration of allegiance and faith, not a statement of fact.  When former Olympian Greg Louganis was brought to Indiana University to speak some years ago, he got a standing ovation when he declared: "One thing I do know -- it's not a choice!"  I'm still puzzling over why he got such a reaction from his predominantly gay audience.  Did he or they think it took any courage to make that assertion -- that he is a poor pitiful victim of his biology?  Maybe, but more likely it was just that he had uttered a shibboleth that marked him One of Us and not One of Them, though I still don't see why gay people throw such hissyfits over the issue. And I stress it here because Conflicted returns to the issue later in his cri de coeur.

Conflicted tells us that he grew up in the Midwest, presumably in the 90s, but now lives somewhere on the West Coast.  He has told numerous carefully-selected co-religionists of his "story," and says he has received uniformly "deep compassion and support from them."  "(I eagerly await the day when homosexual Christians will not be afraid to fully share their lives with others)", but he's not too eager.  That day will come only when more gay Christians stop hiding.  Which isn't to say that I blame him for his fear, or for his choice not to tell more people.  Everyone has to decide for him or herself how much to expose to those around him, and it's not for me to say that his fears are unreasonable or that he must fight them.  But it's also an historical reality that it only became safer for gay people to come out as more and more of us did so, before Conflicted was born.  That includes people who came out in their churches, and challenged other believers to deal with them.  If Conflicted chooses not to take up his cross and come, follow his Lord, that is his business, but he seems to be trying to ignore those in the churches who've made different choices.

On marriage Conflicted declares:
I have been on all sides of this issue at different points in my life, and my position is constantly evolving. As a relative traditionalist on the issue of same-sex marriage, I find myself in a difficult spot. I can see clear constitutional reasons for allowing people of the same-sex to marry one another.  And yet I know that if same-sex marriage becomes normalized, the generations after me will come against significant attack for believing otherwise. Honestly, I think it boils down to an issue of semantics for me. I, like most Christians, believe marriage to be an institution consecrated by God; how then, can it be in direct opposition to his commandments in the Bible? An increasingly common solution has been to advocate civil unions as an alternative to gay marriage. This offers an equitable, legal solution without the religious implications of the term "marriage." It seems petty, I know, but if you note that in the Bible it refers to Jesus Christ as a "Word," you will understand the significance of semiology in the Judeo-Christian tradition. And, in favor of brevity (which by this point seems to have been all but lost), I will forgo the issue of civil rights and the comparison to "separate but equal" seen in the Jim Crow laws of the South, although I have struggled with this issues as well.
Well, he's only twenty-four.  He even has a point (though his theology is garbled) that words matter, which is why the champions of same-sex marriage are not going to settle for "civil unions."  But since words do matter, he needs to think about saying that marriage is "an institution consecrated by God."  If he really believes that, he should object to the secular State intruding on the consecrated institution of  marriage at all.  Heterosexual civil marriage, from this kind of Christian perspective, ought to be unacceptable; as I've argued before, it ought to be as much an oxymoron as civil baptism would be.  Those antigay Christians, from Barack Obama down, who talk about the sanctity of marriage, should be pushing for a separation of church and state to preserve that sanctity.  Let everyone have civil unions, as you find in much of Europe, and leave marriage to religion.  But even if civil unions preserved all the perks of civil marriage, American heterosexuals and homosexuals alike would reject it.  As long as that is the case, however, the notion of marriage as "consecrated" must be set aside.

Churches don't have to be fair or equitable, but governments do.  If the US did institute something as absurd as civil baptism, it couldn't be withheld from anyone, even non-Christians, even atheists.  Denying civil marriage to same-sex couples is so obviously discriminatory that a majority of Americans now can see the unfairness.  Which means that even religious marriage for same-sex couples -- already happening in some denominations -- won't be far behind, not because of government pressure but from internal pressure within the churches.  Whether that conforms to biblical commandments is moot: even the most conservative sects (Roman Catholicism aside) have dropped the opposition to divorce, based in Jesus' explicit teaching, that they maintained fiercely through the 1970s, and many of them are coming to an uneasy peace with homosexuality, even to "union" ceremonies for couples.  Conflicted may hold to the biblical prohibition of sex between males, but I would be amazed if he keeps all the commandments; no believer does, or can.

Back to biology.
Many in the church, including me, recognize the biological aspects of the issue, which further complicates the picture for Believers. How could a loving God allow someone to have intense attractions that they are not allowed to act on? But as Christians, we have to believe that there is something more important than personal liberty, that obedience to the most important and meaningful thing in the universe will supersede and fulfill all of our desires.
Keep telling yourself that, youngster.  To repeat: the "biological aspects" are anything but settled.  But I agree with Conflicted, for what it's worth, that biology doesn't settle the issue.  Yahweh allows, indeed endows his creatures with intense attractions that they're not allowed to act on: no one seems to doubt that extramarital lust is natural, yet it is as forbidden to heterosexuals as genital connection is to homosexuals -- with the crucial difference that heterosexuals are allowed a licit sexual outlet (better to marry than to burn, as Paul told the Corinthians) and homosexuals are not.  To say nothing of the New Testament's endorsement of total sexual abstinence for everybody.  Even outside of religion, some people have chosen celibacy.  (I'm thinking, for example, of the sociologist Edgar Z. Friedenberg, who shocked other gay radicals of the mid-1970s by coming out as gay and as celibate.  Though I've made other choices, I can still relate to Friedenberg's remark about the pleasure he took in handsome men's company: "Sublimation?  Hell, no.  It was photosynthesis.")  People are entitled to make their own choices, including highly uncommon ones.

Speaking of generational matters, Conflicted says: "Recently, I've seen many of the less conservative congregations begin having corporate dialogue about homosexuality."  "Recently"?  This corporate dialogue has been going on since the 1960s at least, before Conflicted was born.  It's not his fault that he's too young to remember those days, but Conflicted reveals with remarks like this that he hasn't really thought very deeply or broadly about homosexuality and Christianity, and hasn't taken time to inform himself even minimally.  It's good to read this young man's perspective, but as I said before about Friedersdorf's remarks about non-bigoted opposition to homosexuality, is this the best they have to offer?  It seems to be.

Friday, March 1, 2013

Reading Entirely for Pleasure Now

I stumbled on a little book at the library called So You Don't Want to Go to Church Anymore: An Unexpected Journey by Wayne Jacobsen and Dave Coleman (Windblown Media, 2006).  Its premise is that the protagonist meets a man who "just might be one of Jesus' original disciples -- still living in the twenty-first century ... That's Jake's dilemma as he meets a man who talks of Jesus as if he had known him, and whose way of living challenges everything Jake had previously known."  Lots of alarm signals there, but it's a small book and I decided to see what the authors made of their idea.

The cold I've had this week has put a damper on my ability to read stuff that actively annoys me, however, so for now I'm going to put the book aside.  It's due at the library tomorrow, so maybe I'll try it again later.  Here's where I got to on my first try.

Jake has a twelve-year-old daughter with asthma, and though he's a Christian he clearly hasn't been getting the strength and support from his God that Christian marketing promises.  He remembers his first encounter with the man who just might be one of Jesus' original disciples.  The stranger informs a squabbling crowd in the street:
"He was nothing special to look at.  He could walk down the street today and not one of you would even notice him.  In fact he had the kind of face you would shy away from, certain he wouldn't fit in with your crowd.
That seems a bit self-contradictory: someone whose face you'd shy away from is not someone who is "nothing special to look at."
"But he was as gentle a man as one would ever know.  He could silence detractors without ever raising his voice.  He never bullied his way; never drew attention to himself nor did he ever pretend to like what vexed his soul.  He was real, to the very core...

"And with all that love, he was completely honest.  Yet even when his actions or words exposed people's darkest motives, they didn't feel shamed.  They felt safe, really safe with him.  His words carried not even a hint of judgment, simply an entreaty to come to God... [18]."
And so on.

Well, maybe.  We don't, in fact, know anything about the historical Jesus: nothing about his appearance, how old he was when he died, we can't be sure about what he said or taught or did.  Our surest historical information is that he was crucified sometime between 26 and 36 CE, because Pontius Pilate was the Roman prefect or procurator of Judea during those years, and there's general agreement that Jesus was executed under Pilate's administration.  That could conceivably be wrong too, but there's no evidence against it at present.

But if the stranger's description is accurate, it is utterly at odds with the gospels' depiction of Jesus, and I don't think that Jacobsen and Coleman want to discredit the canonical gospels.  They want to discredit some present-day people's idea of what Jesus was like, and gather them to the fold of some form of orthodox Christianity.

Any reading of a text will be subjective, but I can't see how anyone reading the gospels would come away with the impression of Jesus as a consistently gentle person, one who never judged, one who never raised his voice, one who never bullied, one who didn't draw attention to himself.  Hello!  Wandering around Galilee and drawing crowds in the thousands, doing faith healing and exorcisms and nature miracles drew attention to him, and unless he was barely sentient he knew what he was doing.  The cleansing of the Temple was hardly the act of a person who didn't care if he was noticed or not -- all the more so if, as some interpreters complain, it was a purely symbolic gesture that achieved nothing except to hasten his arrest and death.  According to the gospels Jesus drew attention to himself because that was his mission: to proclaim the good news, to arouse enmity, and to die on the cross.

Throughout the gospels Jesus is judgmental, dividing the sheep from the goats, the elect from the denied, the saved from the damned.  I'm not sure how you can read a saying like "You snakes!  You brood of vipers!  How will you escape condemnation to hell?" (Matthew 23:33) and not get a strong feeling of judgment.  As for bullying, when Simon Peter denied that Jesus as messiah would have to die, Jesus reportedly responded, "Get behind me, Satan!  You think as men think, not as God thinks!" (Mark 8:33).  Again, I suppose that someone sufficiently determined could read that -- a master reproving his disciple, with all the authority issues it implies -- as not-bullying, but I can't.  Decide for yourself.

Of course this is more or less what I expected, and one reason I think I should try to read the entire book is to try to figure out what the authors think they're doing: do they have any notion at all of how they've departed from the same scriptures they presumably regard as the true record of Jesus and his teaching?  I have no objection to people just making stuff up, but I do marvel at the doublethink it takes to make it up without noticing you're diverging drastically from your source material, and indeed insisting that you're only submitting to its truth.

Imagine that someone wrote a little book about someone who he thought might have known Frodo Baggins, and this someone told how people misunderstand Frodo: they think he's a tiny, bookish little guy, but in fact he was a mighty warrior, seven feet tall and three ax handles across the shoulders, who spent his nights carousing and wenching in the taverns before he went on his quest of the Ring.  When you're writing fiction you can do pretty much what you want, but would anyone agree that this was the "real" Frodo?  It seems to me that Jacobsen and Coleman, far from challenging modern Christians' ideas of Jesus, constructed the Jesus they'd like to believe in themselves.  And not just they, but many other Christians as well.